MLS #44350
West Tisbury Real Estate

Historic West Tisbury Farmhouse with Guest Cottage Set on 1.27 acres in the heart of West Tisbury, this historic four-bedroom farmhouse and separate one-bedroom guest cottage offer a rare opportunity to create a quintessential Martha’s Vineyard family compound. Ideally located near Alley’s General Store, 7a Foods, and North Tisbury Village, the property also provides convenient access to beaches and up-Island towns. The main house blends historic Vineyard character with comfortable modern living. A bright kitchen with vaulted ceilings, center island, Verona gas range, and walk-in pantry opens naturally into the dining and sitting areas, where exposed beams, period plaster walls, wide pine floors, and one of two brick fireplaces create warmth and authenticity throughout. The first floor includes three bedrooms, a full bath, and a separate living room with built-ins and a second fireplace. Upstairs, the private fourth bedroom features original king’s wood paneling, wide floorboards, custom millwork, and an additional full bath. Privately positioned at the rear of the property, the detached one-bedroom guest cottage offers excellent flexibility for guests, extended family, or rental income. Built in 1970, the cottage includes an open living area, bonus loft, spacious deck, outdoor shower, private yard, and separate parking. With expansive lawn space for entertaining, gardening, and outdoor enjoyment, this special West Tisbury property captures the timeless charm and relaxed lifestyle of Martha’s Vineyard. Both homes have passed Title V septic inspections.