MLS #44225
Edgartown Real Estate

An exceptional offering in the heart of Edgartown Village, 14 Thayer Street presents the rare combination of estate-scale grounds, privacy, and an in-town location. Set across an extraordinary 0.62-acre double lot, the property unfolds as a private retreat just moments from the harbor, shops, galleries, and restaurants of downtown Edgartown. Expansive lawns, mature landscaping, and a substantial swimming pool create a setting more often associated with properties well beyond the Village center, offering remarkable space for outdoor living, entertaining, and generations of summer gatherings. At the heart of the property is a distinguished five-bedroom, five-bath residence encompassing more than 3,100 square feet. Rich in authentic Vineyard character, the home is attributed to Frederick Baylies Jr., builder of Edgartown’s iconic Old Whaling Church, lending architectural significance to an already exceptional property. Yet it is the combination of land, location, and lifestyle that truly distinguishes 14 Thayer Street. Opportunities to own this level of acreage and privacy within Edgartown Village are exceedingly limited, making this a compelling chance to acquire a true in-town estate in one of Martha’s Vineyard’s most coveted settings.